Questions tagged [virtual-particles]

Use for computational-device notional particles which are not observable in the lab, such as "off-the-mass-shell" particles, "spurions", renormalons, merons. Do not use for unobserved hypothetical particles such as the graviton, or Goldstone bosons which could have been observable, but got rearranged into other particles through QFT mechanisms.

A virtual particle is a notional intermediate computational device, often in perturbation theory, whose mathematical form resembles that of actual, observable particles, except it relaxes crucial properties of such particles, such as mass; it is then said to be "off mass shell", that is, it violates the relativistic constraint between mass, momentum and energy. It may have negative energy, progress backwards in time, or travel faster than light, all the while preserving some basic physics laws like energy-momentum conservation.

By the end of the calculation, no virtual particles remain to be observed, e.g. in a collision or decay phenomenon: the virtual particles may be visualized as "short-lived" intermediate props in the calculation: the farther off the mass shell (the larger their debt in energy), the shorter their notional (virtual) lifetime.

548 questions
55
votes
5 answers

Why do many people say that virtual particles do not conserve energy?

I've seen this claim made all over the Internet. It's on Wikipedia. It's in John Baez's FAQ on virtual particles, it's in many popular books. I've even seen it mentioned offhand in academic papers. So I assume there must be some truth to it. And…
52
votes
3 answers

Are W & Z bosons virtual or not?

W and Z bosons are observed/discovered. But as force carrying bosons they should be virtual particles, unobservable? And also they require to have mass, but if they are virtual they may be off-shell, so are they virtual or not.
49
votes
5 answers

Do virtual particles actually physically exist?

I have heard virtual particles pop in and out of existence all the time, most notable being the pairs that pop out beside black holes and while one gets pulled away. But wouldn't this actually violate the conservation of energy?
42
votes
3 answers

Deriving the Coulomb force equation from the idea of virtual photon exchange?

Since Newton's law of gravitation can be gotten out of Einstein's field equations as an approximation, I was wondering whether the same applies for the electromagnetic force being the exchange of virtual photons. Is there an equation governing the…
39
votes
4 answers

Can virtual particles be thought of as off-shell Fourier components of a field?

I just found this blog post, which gives an interpretation of virtual particles I haven't seen before. Consider a 1D system of springs and masses, where the springs are slightly nonlinear. A "real particle" is a regular $\cos(kx-\omega t)$…
knzhou
  • 107,105
39
votes
3 answers

The exchange of photons gives rise to the electromagnetic force

Pardon me for my stubborn classical/semiclassical brain. But I bet I am not the only one finding such description confusing. If EM force is caused by the exchange of photons, does that mean only when there are photons exchanged shall there be a…
34
votes
5 answers

What physical evidence is there that subatomic particles pop in and out of existence?

What physical evidence shows that subatomic particles pop in and out of existence?
28
votes
1 answer

What force particle mediates electric fields and magnetic fields?

The force carrier for magnetic fields and electric fields are supposedly photons. I don't get it: 1) Wouldn't that mean that a charged particle (e.g. an electron or even a polarized H2O molecule) would constantly be losing endergy from sending out…
28
votes
2 answers

Why are real photons so much less efficient in carrying momentum than virtual photons?

When two like magnetic poles are brought together, there's a repulsive force felt that's inversely proportional to their separation. In the standard model, the answer to "What is transmitting this repulsive force through empty space between the two…
28
votes
2 answers

Virtual photon description of $B$ and $E$ fields

I continue to find it amazing that something as “bulky” and macroscopic as a static magnetic or electric field is actually a manifestation of virtual photons. So putting on your QFT spectacles, look closely at the space near the pole of a powerful…
27
votes
5 answers

What actually are virtual particles?

What actually are virtual particles? In various places around physics SE, documentaries and occasional news headlines, I see the term "virtual particles", normally virtual photons. I have tried researching it, but I'm not at a level of understanding…
Alex Robinson
  • 1,182
  • 12
  • 22
26
votes
3 answers

Nature of gravity: gravitons, curvature of space-time or both?

General relativity tells us that what we perceive as gravity is curvature of space-time. On the other hand (as I understand it) gravity can be understood as a force between objects which are exchanging (hypothetical) virtual particles called…
23
votes
5 answers

Was Stephen Hawking's explanation of Hawking Radiation in "A Brief History of Time" not entirely accurate?

I've been looking into black holes and Hawking radiation recently (just on the surface level) and was reading "A Brief History in Time" by Stephen Hawking to understand the basics of Hawking radiation. Then I came across a website online which…
22
votes
2 answers

Virtual particles and physical laws

Recently, I was reading about Hawking Radiation in A Brief History of Time. It says that at no point can all the fields be zero and so there's nothing like empty space(quantum fluctuation etc.). Now, the reason mentioned was that…
21
votes
2 answers

Virtual photons, what makes them virtual?

The wikipedia page "Force Carrier" says: The electromagnetic force can be described by the exchange of virtual photons. The virtual photon thing baffles me a little. I get that virtual particles are supposed to be short lived, but as photons live…
1
2 3
36 37