7

I'm currently reviewing some of my notes on Quantum Field Theory (the version of Greiner) and I was wondering if QFT always works in the Hartree-Fock approximation ? Or at least that's what it seems to me!

We have our field-operators $\hat{\psi}(\vec{r},t)$ and $\hat{\psi}^\dagger(\vec{r},t)$ which annihilate or create a particle in $(\vec{r},t)$. By using the appropriate commutation-relations we get fermions or bosons. But these are ONE-PARTICLE operators which obey the correct commutation-relations, or which give the right symmetry (using Fock-space structure).

Now intuïtively I can see this for the free-particle Hamiltonians that this will give an exact result since we'll be able to rewrite them as:

$\hat{H}_0=\sum\limits_nE_n\hat{a}^\dagger_n\hat{a}_n,$

which indeed yields a result in the sense of product functions (since every eigenfunction of $\hat{a}^\dagger_n\hat{a}_n$ is also one of $\hat{H}_0$.

Now the problem starts when we get two-particle (of many-particle) interactions since the Hamiltonian isn't diagonizable in any easy way. This forces us to use perturbation theory and hence the scattering matrix. Upon applying Wick's theorem we can chop up the n-th order term of the scatering matrix into operators of the form $\hat{a}^\dagger_n\hat{a}_n$ which we can calculate in terms of our product basis. Which can also be expressed in terms of a product basis set.

Now long question short: Do we always work in the Hartree-Approximation when we're doing QFT, or am I mistaken?

Nick
  • 3,152

1 Answers1

4

No, the Hartree approximation is only the very simplest of the approximations used. Moreover, it only works for bosoonic fields, for QED or QCD, which contain fermions, one needs at least the Hartree-Fock approximation.

The Hartree approximation and Hartree-Fock approximation are called mean field approximations as the influence of all other particles to a single particle is accounted for only in an averaged way. Mean field approximations are often reasonable first approximations but don't show important features of realistic QFTs, such as anomalous dimensions.