2

Edit: What can be explained by wave-particle duality that cannot be explained by waves?

My understanding of the Standard Model is that what we observe as a particle is really a quantized wave packet, and that all particle phenomenon can be described in that way. This answer states that quantum fields are both wave-like and particle-like.

For example, at low intensities, light is detected as single particles. Can that not be explained by the wave interacting with the detector in such a way that the wave collapses to a point, which is necessarily quantized? In what way is the Standard Model not describable purely as waves in quantum fields?

Someone cited particle tracks through a bubble chamber as a reason why wave-only is insufficient. Can this not be described as quantized wave packets?

1 Answers1

1

"No, it's really that this mysterious wave-particle duality means that photons have the properties of both particles and waves." is exactly right. It's meaningless to ask what is "really" going on as John Bell showed us that there is no (local) "reality."

As Mermin says: there are only correlations (between measurements) but there are no correlates (things that are correlated).

A persistent belief that there is some "reality" is the biggest block to understanding quantum mechanics.

mike stone
  • 58,971
  • 4
  • 53
  • 158