2

Naively, I think the simplest way to include gravity in the Standard Model is to treat the metric $g$ as a variable in the Lagrangian $\mathcal{L}_{SM} $ defined on a (compact) time-orientable Lorentzian manifold $(M,g)$ (reference: Mathematical Gauge Theory With Applications to the Standard Model of Particle Physics by Mark J.D. Hamilton).

\begin{aligned} \mathscr{L}_{SM} & =\mathscr{L}_D[\Psi, A]+\mathscr{L}_H[\Phi, A]+\mathscr{L}_Y\left[\Psi_L, \Phi, \Psi_R\right]+\mathscr{L}_{YM}[A] \\ & =\operatorname{Re}\left(\bar{\Psi} D_A \Psi\right)+\left\langle d_A \Phi, d_A \Phi\right\rangle_E-V(\Phi)-2 g_Y \operatorname{Re}\left(\bar{\Psi}_L \Phi \Psi_R\right)-\frac{1}{2}\left\langle F_M^A, F_M^A\right\rangle_{Ad(P)}\end{aligned}

(Here $D_A$ is Dirac operator with respect to metric $g$ and connection $1$-form $A$ of a principal $U(1)\times SU(2)\times SU(3)$-bundle $P$, $d_A$ is an exterior covariant derivative with respect to $A$, $E$ is a vector bundle whose structure group is $U(1)\times SU(2)\times SU(3)$, $\left\langle\,, \right\rangle_E$ is product of "$U(1)\times SU(2)\times SU(3)$-invariant bundle metric of $E$" and "inner product of $1$-form of $M$, $Ad(P)$ is the adjoint vector bundle, $F_M^A\in\Omega$ is $Ad(P)$-valued $2$-form induced from curvature $2$-form $F_A$ with respect to connection $1$-form $A$ and, $\left\langle \,,\,\right\rangle_{Ad(P)}$ is product of "inner product of $Ad(P)$" and "inner product of $2$-form of $M$".)

Please note that $D_A$ includes $g$ as spin connection (spin connection can be written by using Levi-Civita connection) and innner product of forms are calculated by using metric $g$ and then include metric (more precisely, induced metric $g^*$ on the cotangent vector bundle $T^*M$).

Also $\sqrt{g}$ appears in the action integral as volume form.

I’ve seen a Lagrangian that contains the Ricci scalar. However the $\mathcal{L}_{SM}$ already contains terms which include $g$ and it doesn't seem we should add Ricci scalar to the Lagrangian since metric is coupled to all fields in $\mathcal{L}_{SM}$ (universal gravitation).

Is there a problem with simply treating the metric in the Standard Model Lagrangian as a dynamical variable? I think gravity can be quantized by path integral (of cause we need to be careful not to add equivalent metrics and probably integrate with respect to equivalent class of manifold $M$).

Edit

I would like to ask: If we treat the metric in the Standard Model Lagrangian on a Lorentz manifold as a variable (without adding the Ricci scalar), does the theory become non-renormalizable?

I naively think we don't need to add Ricci scalar term to Lagrangian because I think the Einstein field equations are statistical-mechanical equations that emerge when dealing with a large number of particles, and that they can be derived from the theory of QFT of the $\mathcal{L}_{SM}$.

2 Answers2

8

The Ricci scalar term gives you the so-called Einstein–Hilbert action. This is the action that will give rise to the Einstein equations in the classical theory. In other words, it is the term that actually makes the metric dynamical. It tells you how the gravitational degrees of freedom should behave, and which equations the metric obeys.

As for quantization, things are more subtle. The issue with quantum general relativity is that it leads to a nonrenormalizable theory. This means it receives infinitely many quantum corrections that should be fixed by experiment. You would need to perform infinitely many experiments to fix all the corrections, and hence the theory is no longer predictive. At low energy scales, we can neglect the corrections, and your proposal would work as en effective field theory. At higher energy scales (comparable to the Planck length), which are the cases in which quantum gravity effects really start to become interesting, the theory would break down.

2

Is there a problem with simply treating the metric in the Standard Model Lagrangian as a dynamical variable?

This is close to an idea of induced gravity formulated by Sakharov in 1967: gravitational dynamics emerges via quantum corrections from the matter sector, including Einstein-Hilbert term (Ricci scalar) appearing in one-loop effective Lagrangian.

The English translation of the original (quite short) paper has been republished as part of Golden Oldies (free pdf).

A (relatively) modern perspective on the idea with review of further results by Visser.

A.V.S.
  • 17,324