12

In modern QFT textbooks, renormalization is usually introduced through loop calculations of $\phi^4$ theory. The explicit calculation introduces the fact that counterterms have to be used in the Lagrangian that "absorb" the integral divergences.

However, is there a general procedure to know what types of counterterms to consider, i.e. what form they must take, just by looking at the original Lagrangian?

This question was inspired by various multiple choice questions in graduate-level exams where, given a specific Lagrangian and a divergent loop diagram, one should select the correct form of the counterterms.

Qmechanic
  • 220,844

2 Answers2

11

In a renormalizable relativistic quantum field theory (QFT) in $d=4$ space-time dimensions, the general rule for constructing the Lagrangian is the follwing: Write down all possible local terms with (operator) dimension $\le 4$ respecting the space-time symmetries (Poincare invariance of the action integral) and possibly further internal symmetries.

Example: The list of all allowed terms for a renormalizable Poincare-invariant QFT with a single real scalar field $\phi(x)$ without any further additional symmetries is given by \begin{align} \phi, & \quad (\text{operator dimension} \; [\phi]=1), \\[5pt] \phi^2, & \quad ([\phi^2]=2),\\[5pt] \phi^3, & \quad ([\phi^3]=3), \\[5pt] \phi^4, & \quad ([\phi^4]=4), \\[5pt] (\partial_\mu \phi) (\partial^\mu \phi), & \quad ([(\partial_\mu \phi)(\partial^\mu \phi)]=4). \end{align} Remarks:

  1. Total derivative terms like $\partial_\mu \partial^\mu \phi$ (dimension $3$) or $\partial_\mu \partial^\mu \phi^2$ (dimension $4$) can be ignored as $\int d^4x\, \partial_\mu \ldots= \int d\sigma_\mu \ldots\to 0$ (surface term) in the action integral.
  2. The dimension $4$ term $-\phi \, \partial_\mu \partial^\mu \phi$ is equivalent to $\partial_\mu \phi\, \partial^\mu \phi$ following from partial integration $-\int d^4x\, \, \phi\, \partial_\mu \partial^\mu \phi = \int d^4x \ (\partial_\mu \phi) (\partial^\mu \phi) $.
  3. A term like $\phi\, a_\mu \partial^\mu\phi$ with a constant $4$-vector $a_\mu$ is forbidden as it violates Poincare symmetry.

Imposing the additional discrete symmetry $\phi \to -\phi$ on the Lagrangian reduces the allowed (linear independent) terms to $$ \phi^2, \; \phi^4, \; (\partial_\mu \phi) \, \partial^\mu \phi. $$ The corresponding QFT is referred to as $\phi^4$ theory. The counterterms of this model are thus given by $$ \Delta \mathcal{L}= c_1 (\partial_\mu \phi) (\partial^\mu \phi)+ c_2 \phi^2 + c_3 \phi^4, $$ where the constants $c_{1,2,3}$ can be tuned in such a way that the UV-divergences generated in the loop expansion can be absorbed to all orders, such that observable quantities (mass of the associated scalar particle and scattering cross sections) remain finite. Note that (because of renormalizability), the terms occuring in the counter-term Lagrangian $\Delta \mathcal{L}$ have the same structure as the terms in the tree Lagrangian $$ \mathcal{L}_0 = \frac{1}{2} (\partial_\mu \phi) (\partial^\mu \phi) - \frac{m^2}{2} \phi^2- \frac{\lambda}{4!} \phi^4 $$ you are starting with.

Further details can be found in any text book on (relativistic) QFT.

Hyperon
  • 10,007
4

Prahar's above comment is exactly right: The point is that one must for consistency as a minimum include all possible renormalizable terms that are not excluded by symmetry, cf. the totalitarian principle, even if they were absent at some scale.

For instructive examples, see e.g. this, this & this related Phys.SE posts.

Qmechanic
  • 220,844