0

The concept of differentiability is fundamental to Physics. For instance, already second Newton's law $$\mathbf{F} = m \frac{\mathrm{d}^2 s}{\mathrm{d}t^2}$$ involves the second derivative of space respect to time, so it is implicitly assuming that space as a function of time is differentiable at least two times.

I wonder: Has the question of how many times the fundamental physical quantities are differentiable (respect to time or other fundamental quantities) been investigated?

I understand that:

  • The answer may depend on the branch of Physics (classical, relativistic, quantum...).

  • It is important not to conflate the physical model with the actual phenomenon. For instance, already in classical mechanics we have "non-differentiable" velocities when it comes to perfect elastic bounces, but this seems just a limit of the model. Indeed, better models (dropping the "perfect" assumption) restore differentiability.

  • High order derivatives of position are used in engineering (up to the 6th derivative of position), but this is done in a pragmatic way, the question if, say, position is really derivable 100 times is not considered.

Qmechanic
  • 220,844
en-drix
  • 101

0 Answers0