2

Consider a box with two compartments separated by a semipermeable membrane. The first compartment is initially at pressure $P_0$ and contains the solvent ; the second compartment is initially at pressure $P_1$ and contains the solvent and a solute.

In deriving the van't Hoff my textbook says that we consider the system at equilibrium , yet it says that the two pressures are different at equilibrium. Isn't equality of pressures of subsystems a condition for equilibrium?

Qmechanic
  • 220,844
lohey
  • 135

1 Answers1

1

In thermodynamics we can have partial equilibrium depending on the presence or absence of constraints. Suppose we divide a box into two parts: the equilibrium conditions between the two parts depend on the the properties of the wall:

  • If the wall is impermeable, fixed, and conducting, we only have thermal equilibrium. The pressure and chemical potentials in each part are not allowed to equilibrate.

  • If the wall is impermeable, movable and insulating, then we only have mechanical equilibrium. i.e., pressure is equalized but temperature and chemical potential are not.

  • In the osmotic experiment the wall is fixed, conducting and semipermeable. This leads to thermal and chemical equilibrium between two parts that are at different pressures.

Themis
  • 5,951