1

In gauge theories such as QED or QCD, are the rest energies, and therefore the invariant masses, of various bound states, such as those of positronium or charmonium, gauge-invariant observable quantities?

It seems obvious to me that they must be, but I need confirmation from reliable experts in quantum field theory to refute arguments in other threads that energy is in general gauge-dependent and that only energy differences are observable.

If these energies are not gauge-invariant observables, then I would like to understand why not.

For context, the arguments have been in the following threads:

The reasons I have for believing that rest energies of bound states are gauge-independent observables are:

  • It is common to talk about the invariant mass of such states, implying well-defined-ness, gauge-invariance, and observability of the rest-energy.

  • There are well-known gauge-invariant energy-momentum-stress tensors for gauge field theories.

  • Energy curves spacetime and therefore is obviously well-defined, gauge-invariant, and observable.

Once we settle how this works in full quantum field theories, I will post a follow-on question about the gauge-invariance of energies of bound states in non-relativistic quantum mechanics, where I think there are more subtleties since the electromagnetic field isn't quantized.

G. Smith
  • 52,489

0 Answers0