3

Why the central concepts of classical mechanics, viz. Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms cannot address constraint forces like friction and others in dissipative systems?

Qmechanic
  • 220,844

1 Answers1

0

All the kinds of constraints you can have in your, say, lagrangian system must satisfy a relation called ideality of the constraint, which takes into account the so called virtual displacements, indeed it states: $$\sum_i\bar{N}_i\cdot\delta \bar{r}_i=0.$$ This is a statement you use for building your configuration space.

You see that this is a requirement which excludes dynamical frictions as constraints. Nontheless, you can use pure rolling as a constraint since in that case you demonstrate it is ideal.

Bellem
  • 268