3

In electromagnetism, it is often referred to gauges of the electromagnetic field, such as the radiation or Coulomb gauge. As far as I know, the definition of a gauge helps us to redefine the problem in terms of a vector potential and a scalar potential that, since we have some freedom in choosing them, can be chosen in cleverest way it is possible for the given problem.

Here comes my question: is the choice of the gauge a mere mathematical simplification of the given problem? Does this choice have a physical meaning?

My troubles are actually in understanding the physical meaning of this choice of the gauge and what will change if I choose a different gauge.

Qmechanic
  • 220,844
JackI
  • 1,764
  • 10
  • 26

3 Answers3

2

In classical physics, and also quantum gauge field theory with an abelian gauge group (like QED), the choice of gauge has no physical significance whatsoever. It's basically just like choosing where to place the origin of your coordinate system. In nonabelian gauge quantum field theory the situation is a bit more subtle, because large gauge transformations take you between physically distinct states. But this is a rather technical detail, and for the most part you can safely think of gauge choices as completely physically irrelevant.

tparker
  • 51,104
1

Physical observables in a gauge theory$^1$ are independent of gauge-fixing choices$^1$. Conversely, gauge-fixing choices are unphysical.

--

$^1$ Here we have applied a narrow definition of a gauge theory where gauge symmetry represents a redundant description of a physical system, cf. e.g. this Phys.SE question. In other words, we have ignored (large) gauge transformations that actually change the physical configuration, cf. answer by tparker.

$^2$ By a gauge-fixing condition, we assume a condition that intersect each gauge-orbit precisely once. Note that some conditions do not actually fulfill this, e.g. only partially fixes a gauge. Also there might be Gribov problems.

Qmechanic
  • 220,844
-1

The gauge choice or another has the same physical importance as choosing a inertial reference frame or another... the possibility of doing that gets you a lot of truly profound physical implications (by Noether theorem, for example), so both answers are yes, in some sense.

Iliado Odiseo
  • 163