Just to expand a bit on Alfred's answer ...
When you're trying to understand a system in special relativity it's dangerous to throw around factors of gamma and hope you get the correct answer. You need to sit down and do a calculation. This sounds a bit brutal, but the calculation is often simpler than you think. Let's do it for this case.
To make things concrete let's suppose the starship passes us at time zero, and we and the starship captain synchronise our clocks so time zero is when we pass. Let's also suppose the starship is travelling to some star that is a distance $d$ away from us.
In our frame we can identify two spacetime points. The point $(0, 0)$ is when the starship passes us, and the point $(d/v, d)$ is when the starship reaches the star. A quick explanation of that second point: we write points as $(t, x)$. When the starship is at the star $x = d$, and the time taken to reach the star is distance/speed or $d/v$, so the point the starship reaches the star is $(d/v, d)$.
Now let's consider the starship's frame. In this frame the starship is stationary, and by agreement with us on Earth the point the starship passes the earth is (0, 0). We need to work out at what point $(t', d')$ the starship sees the star pass. The value of $d'$ is easy because in the starship's frame it's not moving, so $d' = 0$. All that remains is to work out $t'$.
There are various ways of calculating $t'$, but my favourite is to use the fact that the proper time is an invarient in special relativity. Alfred mentioned the proper time in his answer, and it's given by:
$$ d\tau^2 = c^2dt^2 - dx^2 - dy^2 - dz^2 $$
The key thing about the proper time is that it's an invarient, which means every observer in every inertial frame will measure the same value of $d\tau$. We can use this to calculate $t'$. In our case it's simplified because we are only considering motion in the $x$ direction so $dy$ and $dz$ are both zero.
So, in our frame we calculate $\tau$ to be:
$$ \tau^2 = c^2 \frac{d^2}{v^2} - d^2 $$
In the starship's frame $d'$ is zero so the proper time is simply:
$$ \tau'^2 = c^2t'^2 $$
Both observers must agree on the proper time so $\tau = \tau'$, and setting these equal gives us:
$$ c^2t'^2 = c^2 \frac{d^2}{v^2} - d^2 $$
and a quick simplification gives:
$$ t' = \sqrt{\frac{d^2}{v^2} - \frac{d^2}{c^2}} $$
It would be nice to have $t'$ in terms of $t$ rather than $d$, and we can do this simply by noting that $d = vt$, which gives (after a quick rearrangement):
$$ t' = t\sqrt{1 - \frac{v^2}{c^2}} $$
So the time starship captain measures to reach the star is shorter than the time we measure, as you expected. The calculation now shows you that your equation was wrong as you got the factor of $\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2}$ in the wrong place.
Incidentally, we can also work out what distance the starship captain measures to the star. We and the captain both agree on our relative speed, $v$, so the captain can calculate the distance to the star using $d' = vt'$ and gets:
$$ d' = vt\sqrt{1 - \frac{v^2}{c^2}} $$
and of course $vt$ is just $d$ so:
$$ d' = d\sqrt{1 - \frac{v^2}{c^2}} $$
So the starship captain measures the distance to the star reduced by a factor of $\sqrt{1 - v^2/c^2}$ just like the time.