If our eyes were just big photosensitive plates, then yeah. You'd be facing directly towards the light, the whole wavefront hits/excites the whole photosensitive plate at the same time, and the whole thing is excited. This would make everything look like a blur, because all light from all directions would be present everywhere on your eye.
Instead, our eye uses lenses. Ideally, you want a lens to behave as follows: If you have an infinitely far away object, the lens focuses its parallel rays (or, alternatively, flat wavefront) into a point behind the lens - the focus. In this way the lens turns a direction into a point. Parallel rays coming from a single direction all get focused onto that point.
This sounds magical, that everything in a flat wavefront coming from a given direction can be mapped onto a point, using as dumb an object as a piece of glass, but that's how it works! Indeed it's a bit too magical. In physics it comes about from the "paraxial ray approximation" - that the light rays are close to the axis of your eye or microscope or whatever, and that they move for the most part straight down the axis. You get lots of complicated effects when you try to account for the fact that light is a wave and that things aren't always paraxial.