What is the difference of the gap between superconductor and insulator?

Question

This is what I learned from textbook. An insulator is insulate as the gap between the valence band and the conduction band and the fermi level lies in the gap. A superconductor is super electronically conductive because there is a gap between the BCS ground state with the first excited state. This gap prevents electrons from being backscattered. I'm trying to understand why both have gaps but one is insulator, the other is superconductor.

Answer 1

The difference is that in a normal conductor the current is carried by fermions (i.e. electrons) while in a superconductor the current is carried by bosons (i.e. Cooper pairs).

Have a read through my answer to What is it about the "conduction band" of a material that is distinct from the valence band? where I explain why a full energy band cannot carry a current. In a conventional conductor any momentum eigenstate in the band can be occupied by at most two electrons (with opposite spins) so in a full band the net momentum of the electrons in the band is zero i.e. there is no net drift velocity and hence no current.

In a superconductor the electrons pair up into Cooper pairs that obey Bose-Einstein statistics, so any number of Cooper pairs can occupy the same momentum state. That means the electrons joined into Cooper pairs can have a net momentum, and hence a net drift velocity, so they can carry a current.

Answer 2

In a superconductor, there is a one-particle gap but no two-particle gap. In a true insulator, all n-particle gaps are finite. With a small electric field you can still create gapless two-particle states in a superconductor, which carry a current. This current is non-dissipative because all particles are in a single macroscopic coherent state (the ground state), unlike a metal where the current is carried by single particles in many incoherent single particle states.

Answer 3

Existence of a gap means that ground state and excited states are well separated and a transition from ground state and excited states requires some energy.

Existence of a gap does not determine whether a system is insulating or not. In your case, conductivity is determined by the ground state. For an insulator, the ground state is insulating while ground state of superconductor is superconducting. A gap here means it is not easy for insulator to be excited to carry currents and for superconductors to lose its superconductivity.

Answer 4

Normally Fermi energy is temperature dependent. We define the Fermi level at absolute zero. An insulator at temperatures near absolute zero have very less energy compared to the conduction energies. A superconductor state holds good at very low temperatures (liquid He temperature). The superconducting state is characterized by cooper-pair, which is not to be treated like a normal conduction electron. A normal conduction electron well satisfies Maxwell's equations, but a superconductor do not. So it is better not to mix the ideas of insulators and superconductors. For illuminating discussion on superconductivity, see Introduction to Solid State Physics by Charles Kittel

Answer 5

For an insulator, the energy gap is the difference in the energy of the conduction band and valence band. But for superconducting state, "Gap" means the difference between energies of individual electrons in the Cooper pair near the Fermi energy ($E_F$). These Cooper pair electrons are entangle in spin, position, and momentum, etc.