18

Right now I have a good income from my software engineering job and want to supplement that with a small solar power plant (costing between 5000€ - 7000€) and sell power to the grid.

I would be happy if I could earn 300 - 500€ per month (which is a typical wage in Greece, but way less than my current income). AFAIK a typical ROI is in 5 years on a typical solar power plant.

Do you think it is a good idea to use this approach, so I can have an income not based upon software engineering?

My idea is to have small steady income from selling electricity, so I can use this income to fund a future software project I want to start.

Though my plan may have some drawbacks:

  1. Maintenance: Usually how much is the maintenance cost for a solar power unit?
  2. ROI: Does a typical solar power plant take 5 years to pay for itself?

The unit will be installed in Greece.

Flux
  • 17,301
  • 12
  • 74
  • 138

5 Answers5

24

Whether any investment makes good financial sense depends on a few factors - let's see how this project lines up:

(1) What are the projected revenues from the investment?

  • Looks like you have an expectation of how much this will earn you. Is that based on an actual scientific assessment of how much sunlight would hit your proposed installation area? Make sure you aren't simply assuming the energy output based on, for example, a salesperson telling you what to expect.

  • Do you have actual contracted rates to sell back to your local utility company? This is going to be very jurisdiction dependent. Best case scenario would be a guarantee to buy back electricity at the same cost to use it [meaning they can't undercut what they would pay you compared to what they charge a regular customer].

(2) What are the projected expenses to cover the investment?

  • Installation you have listed as 5-7k, but does that include the land needed to install it? Perhaps you are installing this on the roof of your house - is that the best way to get sunlight based on direction you face? Is it legal in your municipality to have a structure added like that? Are there permits you might need to buy? Would you need to re-shingle your roof in anticipation of having these installed?

  • Maintenance will be the big question - do you have assurance over what long-term maintenance will cost? [especially - has this company / technology been around long enough to even know that?]

(3) What are the risks / how likely is your projected outcome?

  • If you can't get any firm answers on some of the above, then what is the likelihood you are correct? If your revenues are not so guaranteed, you should consider reducing the projected impact of having them.

  • In a 'worst case scenario' where for whatever reason you are unable to sell the power back to the grid, would this produce more power than you need personally? Would you need to buy some large batteries to store energy, and how long would it take to pay off that additional cost?

(4) What is the 'opportunity cost' of spending that money initially?

  • You could take that same 5k and invest it, maybe even buying shares in a diversified renewable energy company. Perhaps that has a lower risk, or a higher risk, and a lower return, or a higher return, than doing it yourself. But it would be less of a headache, too.

  • You could also use that 5k for 'regular' investing, in a diversified index fund or similar, and earn something that way.

  • The point is that if you project that your solar panels would earn you, say, 5% a year, and the stock market could earn you, say, 7% a year, you need to consider if this is higher risk than the stock market.

  • In your case, since you plan on doing a software engineering project 'down the road', installing this solar project would cost you 5k that you could even just use to immediately start funding your project.

And, specifically for something like renewable energy: (5) Are there any government incentives / restrictions to consider?

  • It is quite possible your government could give you some type of tax credit for installing renewable energy equipment. That could be a big impact to the profitability of the idea.

At the end of all the above, from a strictly financial perspective, the simplest mechanical way to figure out the $ impact would be: how many years until the investment pays for itself. My understanding of solar projects is that majority of the cost is simply installation, and they can be mostly self-sufficient as long as: (a) little snowfall occurs in your area; and (b) you can very easily sell energy back to the utility grid without negotiating.

In short, how much energy do you expect to produce, what is the price to sell it back to the grid, and therefore how much do you expect to earn per year? Once you know the annual earnings of the investment, consider how many years it would take to pay for itself, and how many years you should expect the panels to last. If it pays for itself in 5 years, and lasts 20 years, for example, that would be one way to see this as valuable investment.

Edit because this has hit Hot, I've done a bit of digging and thrown in some more specific numbers:

I'm relying on a couple of external sources for the following data, see here: http://www.schellas.gr/en/categories.asp?catid=90 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261366438_Cost_of_PV_electricity_-_Case_study_of_Greece

In short, it looks like you might be able to get 40MWh of power annually from a very large rooftop installation , like over 800 sq ft [hard to tell exactly because technology has advanced a lot over the past 10 years, so old figures of output may be outdated], unsure of the cost of that installation. Looks like you can sell back to PPC at a cost of about 80 Eur / Mwh, so maybe as much as 3,200 EUR per year, or about 260 EUR per month. Looks like your initial estimate of earning about 300 Eur per month might be possible, and if you could get that installed for 7,000 EUR, it would pay for itself in about 2-3 years.

So at a first pass of reasonability, looks like payoff in 5 years could be possible, assuming you are roughly in the ballpark for installation costs, and have a large enough roof. You will note that this is heavily dependent on technology efficiency and government support for electricity buyback. If the government further promotes the idea great, but if they remove support you might no longer get the return you desire. Definitely looks worth it to investigate further!

Grade 'Eh' Bacon
  • 43,067
  • 11
  • 111
  • 164
21

As usual, Bacon's answer is excellent. I'd like to direct some feedback to the data you specifically provided.

Your anticipated cost of the solar power system is 5000€ - 7000€ and you expect to earn 300€ - 500€ per month. If that was a legitimate expectation, I believe everyone would go and make the same investment and Greece would have more solar panels than square meters to place them. Sign me up!

I don't know the power and solar markets in Greece, but I can't imagine it's so drastically different than the US that you would be able to earn that kind of monthly income compared to such a low up-front cost. In the US, the average cost for a 6kW solar system is somewhere around $15500, or 13000€. This is enough to cover the power needs of an average home and maybe put a small amount back into the grid. US power companies rarely offer to pay cash out for what you put back in, but will give credits to your account so when you don't produce enough to cover the home, you might not go out of pocket. Let's call the average monthly power cost $200 when looking at a whole year, that means we would need to go up to a 15+kW system to generate the lowest end of the monthly earnings you suggest. (Apologies, I don't know the power measurement conversions to provide an equivalent system size for Greece.)

BobbyScon
  • 14,104
  • 3
  • 47
  • 63
12

Another aspect that hasn't been mentioned so far, is that the low voltage system in Greece is not capable of maintaining stability while handling energy injections by distributed generation at arbitrary connecting points, and it is currently under stress from the existing installations.

Thus, unless OP is lucky and his land is at a favourable location, the distribution system operator is unlikely to accept to connect to the new installation.

Here is the current availability map, where green is where there is capacity for further absorption:

enter image description here

Sources:

  1. https://apps.deddie.gr/WebAPE/main.html#
  2. https://apps.deddie.gr/WebAPE/map.html
user000001
  • 280
  • 1
  • 6
9

Do you think it is a good idea to use this approach, so I can have an income not based upon software engineering?

If you think you are better at running a solar plant than you are at being a software engineer, yes.

If you're really good at being a software engineer but have no idea how to run a solar plant, no.

We have no idea what your competencies are, but your expectations for profit margin tell us that perhaps solar energy is not a particular area of expertise for you. Given that you don't seem to have a plan for how much power or money you require to meet your objectives, what your operating costs would be, etc, we can also conclude that running a business is also not a particular field of expertise for you.

5000 euro might buy you enough solar panels to make electricity for your own personal use, or perhaps a household of two. There would be little, if any, left over to sell back to the grid. At best you would be able to offset your monthly cost of electricity and perhaps make a small amount back.

The energy sector is one with very thin margins for profit. If you intend to make income, you need to spend more money. Much more. Only with scale and efficiencies of size can you bring your costs down enough to be competitive. You can't dabble in the energy industry — small fish do not survive.

I'd stick with software engineering.

With that said, investing in domestic renewable power like solar really can be a great idea, so all this is not to say that you should not consider adding solar generation to your home, I just wouldn't look at it as a money making venture. It would help offset your energy costs long-term and is an environmentally conscious move to make. It can end up generating a small profit, but nowhere near 300-500€/month.

If you were looking to make significant income from such a project you would be really considering at least 1€ million and up for outlay, and you would need a suitable piece of land to install the number of panels it would take. Maybe with a small piece of land somewhere you could start something smaller, but just to pay the maintenance and carrying costs you will need at least a certain number of panels to provide that income - and you still want to make profit. Whatever the case, it would be a much larger investment than 5k euro.

Flux
  • 17,301
  • 12
  • 74
  • 138
J...
  • 298
  • 2
  • 7
2

Projections are uncertain. Especially when concerning the future. There is no guarantee that the grid owners will pay you in 2 years what they pay now. Many people have the same idea and revenue will drop below profitability. If you do it, do it because you like to provide some 'green' electricity for the sake of doing it. Don't do it if you want to make money. For example, 20 years ago they promised a 4%/year gain in pension funds, now we are at 0.2%/year.

Flux
  • 17,301
  • 12
  • 74
  • 138
biker
  • 21
  • 2