5

According to what I've read on special relativity, $c$ is the speed limit for every object in the universe, and according to Einstein, an object's speed through the three spatial dimensions plus its speed through the fourth temporal dimension always sums to $c$.

I once watched a video demonstrating what it would be like to fall into a black hole. At one point the author stated that if a photon was emitted directly away from the singularity and at a distance equal to the Schwarzschild radius, the photon would hover there for eternity.

My question is based on these assumptions so please let me know if either is incorrect.

With its motion through the spatial dimensions halted, will the photon in question not experience time at roughly the same rate we do? Will it decay?

Qmechanic
  • 220,844
tbyrd
  • 101

1 Answers1

7

First, a couple things:

  • photons do not "experience" time in general, precisely because they always travel at $c$.
  • because of the above point, photons do not decay, either.

To better visualize what's happening, consider that the event horizon is a place where spacetime itself is "falling" into the black hole at the speed of light. So, if you emit a photon precisely as you pass the event horizon, the photon's physical motion through space would be exactly counteracted by the spacetime curvature at the horizon, and it would effectively "hover" at that location.

However, the way that this photon would be observed is very different for different observers:

The in-falling observer, who emits the photon just as she passes the event horizon, will believe that the photon is traveling away from her (at $c$, as usual).

However, a distant observer (far from the black hole) will never see the photon at all. Or rather, to the distant observer, the photon will appear to be infinitely redshifted.

An observer who falls into the black hole after the first in-falling observer still has a chance to observe the photon (not redshifted).

But more practically speaking, this kind of "equilibrium" would be highly unstable (the photon would not be able to "hover" for very long). This is because the black hole's Schwarzschild radius is always changing slightly, whether it's due to the black hole absorbing CMB radiation, or emitting Hawking radiation. So, the photon will eventually either escape, or be dragged deeper into the black hole.

Dmitry Brant
  • 2,547