3

I know the AC loadline is steeper because the load resistance \$r_c = R_C||R_L\$ is low, but a low resistance DOESN'T shift the cutoff voltage. That is because when the BJT is OFF, all the supply voltage \$VCC\$ drops across the BJT \$CE\$ terminals.

From the AC loadline, the voltage \$VCE\$ during cutoff is lower than \$VCC\$.

Where does the additional \$VCC-VCE\$ voltage drop?

enter image description here

enter image description here

across
  • 1,150
  • 12
  • 26
  • Think about the voltage across the bypassed Re, is that different under AC and DC conditions? – Neil_UK Feb 13 '22 at 10:03
  • for AC the drop is $0$ (reactance of bypass capacitor is designed to be $0$ for the operating frequency range). For DC the drop is approximately the bias voltage divider: $\dfrac{R2}{R1+R2}*VCC$. But when the transistor is cutoff, both the AC and DC drops should be $0$ right? @Neil_UK – across Feb 13 '22 at 10:06
  • say input signal is $0.1V AC$. At negative peak of input AC voltage, the voltage across BE junction is $0.7- 0.1$, the voltage at Re is just DC bias and is not affected. Even the AC collector current variations cannot change the voltage at Re because the reactance is $0$. Hmm.. @Neil_UK not so sure – across Feb 13 '22 at 10:26
  • @Neil_UK do you mean the additional $VCC-VCE$ drops across the Re bypass capacitor wow! then the coupling capacitor also will have $Vc$ collector voltage.. it never occurred to me. But I don't fully understand... ty XD – across Feb 13 '22 at 10:38
  • I get it now @Neil_UK the coupling and bypass capacitors hold the dc voltage. For saturation, the bjt "pushes" its VCEQ drop to load resistor Rc. So the saturation occurs when IC = ICQ + VCEQ/Rc. – across Feb 13 '22 at 11:16
  • Similarly for cutoff, the bjt "zeroes" the voltage across Rc, so the maximum change in VCE is ICQ*Rc. Thank you so much it all makes sense! – across Feb 13 '22 at 11:21

2 Answers2

2

The truth about load line

I know full well that my answer here, more than a year from now, will not be as helpful to OP as it would have been then. But nevertheless, I decided to tell this story here - first, because I was impressed by the OP's way of thinking; secondly, because there were no answers and they decided to answer themselves. I understood a long time ago that here not only are the questions important, but also who asks them. I understood a long time ago that here not only the questions are important, but also who asks them.

Beyond the formal explanations

The convenience of textbook formal explanations is that they are simple, concise, easy to remember, and easy to reproduce. Therefore, they work well for teachers and answerers in SE EE :-) who do not want to "waste their time" with "extra" details, and for students who need to do homework or answer a written exam. The disadvantage of these explanations is "only" that they are superficial and practically do not explain, but only tell facts. As a result, we only know circuits but do not understand them.

Circuits are material, tangible... To understand something there, before it can be mathematically described and calculated, it must be seen what exactly it is.

What is load line?

Such a concept, handed down from generation to generation over the centuries, is the so-called "load line". It is presented verbatim only as a straight line without explaining what is hidden behind it.

Real voltage source's IV curve: But it is something quite material - the IV curve of a real (with internal resistance Rc) voltage source Vcc.

schematic

simulate this circuit – Schematic created using CircuitLab

It is obtained as a difference between the IV curve of the "ideal" voltage source Vcc (vertical line)...

Vcc IV curve

... and the inclined to right resistance Rc IV curve.

Rc IV curve

The resulting IV curve is inclined to left and shifted to right with Vcc.

Load line

Amplifier device's IV curve: This real voltage source is loaded by the amplifier device. It has the behavior of a current source; so let's simulate it with such.

schematic

simulate this circuit

Its IV curve is a horizontal line.

Scanning line

Superimposed IV curves: The two devices are connected to each other (in parallel, in series or both, as you like).

schematic

simulate this circuit

Their point of intersection (aka operating point) is the graphical solution of the circuit equation Vcc - Ic.Rc = Vce.

Intersecting lines

Obtaining the load line

To get all the points of the real source IV curve (the load line), we need to scan it by moving (scanning) the current source IV curve. If our goal was to obtain the current source IV curve (to see the transistor output curve), we would have to scan it by moving (scanning) the real voltage source IV curve. Let's now do the former by various scanning devices.

Transistor: If the transistor is driven in a way that it uniformly changes its collector current...

schematic

simulate this circuit

... its horizontal IV curve moves in a vertical direction. The intersection (operating) point moves and plots the load line (there is no DC sweep similation).

STEP 2.1

Current source: Similarly, if a current source uniformly changes its current...

schematic

simulate this circuit

... its horizontal IV curve moves and plots the load line. There is no DC sweep similation because CircuitLab would put the sweeping quantity (current here) on the abscissa and the other (voltage) on the ordinate while the opposite is accepted.

STEP 2.2

Resistor: Here the things are quite different. When a variable resistor changes its resistance from zero to infinity...

schematic

simulate this circuit

... its IV curve rotates and the moving intersection point plots the load line (there is no DC sweep similation because I did not find a way to print the function I = f(V) of sweeping resistance).

STEP 2.3

Voltage source: This is the most convenient way to get the load line because the voltage is put on the abscissa and the current on the ordinate. To see the simulation, enter Simulate > DC Sweep and then click Run DC Sweep. When the voltage source uniformly changes its voltage...

schematic

simulate this circuit

... its vertical IV curve moves in a horizontal direction and plots the load line.

STEP 2.4

Conclusion: It is not absolutely necessary to obtain the load line with the help of a transistor; it can be obtained by any element that can change the current (voltage) between the two points. The most convenient is the voltage source, and therefore we will use it below.

OP's circuit

Let's take advantage of all the wisdom above to test the OP's assumptions in practice.

Whole circuit

I have created below a CircuitLab schematic of the OP's circuit. I have chosen the values of the device parameters so that the DC emitter voltage Ve = 2 V and the quiescent collector voltage Vc = 5 V are obtained.

To see the simulation, enter Simulate > Time Domain > and then click Run Time-Domain Simulation.

schematic

simulate this circuit

In the graph below, the input signal is of such small amplitude (15 mV) that it is almost invisible.

STEP 3.1

DC circuit

Scanning transistor: In accordance to written above, the CircuitLab DC sweep similation will put the sweeping quantity (base current here) on the abscissa and the output quantity (collector current) on the ordinate. But to see the load line, Vce should be on the abscissa. So we cannot directly use the transistor as a scanning device.

schematic

simulate this circuit

Scanning voltage source: As we saw above, we can easily replace the transistor with a varying voltage source representing its Vce voltage.

schematic

simulate this circuit

As we can see, the maximum Vce is 10 V.

STEP 3.3

AC circuit

Voltage sources as capacitors: For the purposes of intuitive understanding, it is convenient to think about charged capacitors as (rechargeable) batteries. So let's replace the capacitors with voltage sources with the same voltage.

schematic

simulate this circuit

Moved ground: In the coordinate system, Vce is on the abcissa. So we have to ground (move the ground to) the emitter.

schematic

simulate this circuit

Moved emitter voltage source: Here we notice that the two voltage sources Ve and Vcc are connected in series. Then let's move Ve to Vcc. Interestingly, Ve turns out to have the opposite polarity to Vcc.

schematic

simulate this circuit

Combined Vcc and Ve: So if we combine them, the resulting voltage of the combined source is Vcc - Ve...

schematic

simulate this circuit

... so the maximum Vce is 8 V.

STEP 3.7

Conclusions

Specific

  • The DC load line is an IV curve of a real voltage source with voltage V = Vcc = 10 V and internal resistance Ri = Rc + Re = 7.55 + 3 = 10.55 kΩ.

  • The AC load line is an IV curve of a real voltage source with voltage V = 8 V and internal resistance Ri = Rc||Re = 4.3 kΩ.

  • The load line has nothing to do with the transistor. It can be obtained by using any 2-terminal device with varying resistance, current or voltage.

  • A variable voltage source is the most convenient scanning device.

Methodological

  • Simulating charged capacitors with rechargeable batteries in AC amplifiers is a powerful heuristic technique for exploring circuits.

  • It allows to replace the AC mode with DC, and to examine circuits manually, step by step, and automatically through a DC Sweep Simulation.

Circuit fantasist
  • 16,664
  • 1
  • 19
  • 61
1

I think I finally understand how bjt amplifies the input signal by converting dc power into ac.

Only two voltages change here:

  1. voltage across bjt
  2. voltage across load resistance \$r_c=R_C||R_L\$

(And the sum of these two voltages is always constant because the other voltages in the circuit do not change)


The reason for confusion in the posted question was neglecting the coupling and bypass capacitors as pointed out by @Neil_UK.

These capacitors hold the DC voltage; AC signal doesn't drop across these capacitors because it takes a lot of time to charge these capacitors and the AC signal doesn't give these capacitors time to charge.

When the AC signal is present, the bjt has only one way to enter either saturation or cutoff:

  • "Push" its \$V_{CEQ}\$ voltage drop over to the load resistor so that an additional ac current of \$\frac{V_{CEQ}}{r_c}\$ can flow. By
    doing this, the bjt goes into saturation; the saturation current is
    $$i_{c(sat)}=I_{CQ}+\frac{V_{CEQ}}{r_c} $$
  • "Zero" the voltage drop across the load resistor so that an
    additional voltage \$I_{CQ}\cdot r_c\$ drops across the bjt. This
    cuts off the bjt and the cutoff voltage is
    $$v_{ce(cutoff)}=V_{CEQ}+I_{CQ}\cdot r_c$$

Through out this process, the dc voltages across emitter bypass capacitor and collector coupling capacitor do not change. They remain fixed at \$V_{EQ}\$ and \$V_{CQ}\$ respectively. The AC signal passes through these capacitors without changing their voltages noticeably!

across
  • 1,150
  • 12
  • 26